The Controversy of the Lottery

In the lottery, participants pay a small sum of money for the chance to win a large sum of money. The winnings are determined by a draw of numbers or other symbols. The lottery has its roots in ancient times, and has been used for everything from distributing property to determining the next king of Israel. It has also been a popular pastime during parties and dinners, such as the apophoreta, in which a host would distribute tickets to guests, who then had a chance of winning extravagant prizes. Lotteries are also found in the Bible, where the casting of lots was used to decide everything from dividing property among a people to deciding who kept Jesus’ garments after His Crucifixion.

In modern times, state-run lotteries are a big business, with sales topping $25 billion in 2021 alone. But they are not without their critics. Some argue that the whole system is corrupt, and that the proceeds are sucked up by unsavory interests. Others complain that lottery revenue is regressive, with poor people spending a higher proportion of their incomes on tickets. Still, some states have been able to make the argument that lottery funds are needed for public services.

One of the most chilling examples is Shirley Jackson’s short story “The Lottery.” The setting is an unnamed small town in June, and it is full of details that capture contemporary small-town life. Little children pile up stones as adults assemble for the annual lottery, and Old Man Warner quotes an old proverb: “Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon.”

Then it is revealed that the lottery is not an ordinary game. It is a ritual that involves selecting a person and collectively stoning her to death. The victim is not guilty of any crime, other than being the wrong number on a slip of paper. The fact that the entire village turns against her, including her children, is what makes the story so powerful.

The lottery has long been a controversial subject. Its critics have argued that it is a form of legalized gambling and exploitation, and that the government should not be in the business of making money from it. Some have pushed for a total ban on lotteries, but others have argued that people will gamble anyway, so the state might as well get its cut. But these arguments overlook a fundamental truth: the purpose of the lottery is not to shield gamblers from exploitation but to raise money. That’s why the games are promoted so aggressively, and why state-run lotteries print gaudy tickets that look like nightclub fliers spliced with Monster Energy drinks.